 |
The Deadpan Debate: Cloning
The
case for by Prof Helmut van Boffinginen of
the Institute for the Pursuit of Perfection
Cloning
should be permitted because it offers us the chance of a brave
new world and one would have to be an irredeemable moron to
disagree. I think that says it all really, but in the remainder
of the small space afforded to me, let me offer just a few of
the many possibilities:
-
Spare-parts warehouses full of headless torsos so that you
could destroy all of your internal organs with drink and drugs
and get a new set at any time.
-
The
resurrection of lost pets or dead children for purely sentimental
or lifestyle reasons. Not to mention new pet trends like sabre-toothed
poodles or woolly-mammoth rabbits.
-
A
host of benefits for re-incarnationists and alien cults.
-
The
chance to have a lot of little “mini-yous” running
all about the place for the general amusement of you and your
friends.
-
Clones
make you feel better about yourself because you can treat
them as second-class citizens whose life is worth less.
-
Clones
make the perfect slaves for both work and sexual purposes,
and if you accidentally kill one, you can just make a new
one.
-
And finally, immortality! You can have your brain transplanted
into a new body at any time and live forever. And when you
have a brain as brilliant as mine (and I know that you don’t),
the possibilities are truly limitless.
The
case against by the Rev. Elvin J Whipple of
Sacred Angels Church, San Francisco
I am blessed,
blessed that each time I stand in my pulpit and gaze down on my
beloved flock I see the face of God. His visage radiates out at
me from each and every soul in the congregation, and for that
I am truly grateful. Yet, when I read about the possibility of
human cloning I, a humble man of the cloth, more than despair
as I weep. The Lord created us all in his image and what these
scientists are seeking to do usurps his majesty. Human cloning
is not progress, it is the antipathy of progress! Cloning is but
a step away from replacing humans with robots. Where will it end?
When I look
at my flock I don’t want to see Dolly the Sheep, all arthritic
and wheezy, with nothing to do but bleat on about various ailments.
I want my charge to be fit, strapping and human, something sad
Dolly could never be.
The advocates
of human cloning point to the many diseases that could be eradicated
if we pursue this course of action. Perhaps some disorders will
be, I’ll concede this. Yet, by thunder, have they not pondered
the generically modified diseases, the mutated maladies, that
might rear their ugly heads to smite our race?
If I might
be allowed I would like to digress here for a moment, I should
like to deliver a short allegory to support my views. Many years
ago I took a slow boat to Tangiers, in order to spread the word
of God to these poor young men who plied their trade in the city’s
houses of ill repute. One morning, after a particularly hard session,
spent mostly on my knees before my congregation, I awoke with
a severe pain in my gut. This was undoubtedly due to the perfumed
figs I had devoured the night before. My stomach, you see, was
not used to this source of protein.
What I am
saying is that how can we, the human race, hope to counter afflictions
that would render us indisposed? This genetically perfected pernicious
fiddling could bring forth the four horsemen of the apocalypse
and for this reason alone we must stave off our carnal desires
for the perfect man.
|